How Data Displays Influence Plant Awareness
Master's Thesis▫️Role: Sole researcher▫️Project language: English▫️Methods: IoT prototyping, data physicalization, diary study, semi-structured interview
Master's Thesis▫️Role: Sole researcher▫️Project language: English▫️Methods: IoT prototyping, data physicalization, diary study, semi-structured interview
Plants tend to be ignored compared to animals, yet plants are important for sustainability on Earth. This disparity affects people’s willingness to support plant conservations for sustainable future. To what extent can different modalities of data displays in a plant monitoring system influence human-plant connection, and eventually plant awareness?
How does the modality of plant monitoring system influence human-plant relationship? How does this modality and relationship influence plant awareness?
Plant care and plant monitoring of houseplants with IoT system in home setting
For the plant monitoring system, an IoT system with two modalities (data physicalization vs. screen display) was developed, as a way to display environmental plant condition.
The potted plants were attached with sensors measuring: CO2, temperature, humidity, soil moisture, light. These sensors send their measurement to either the data physicalization or the screen display.
The data physicalization is custom designed (3D printed), and consists of two arms which can curl or droop depending on the measured variables. When the plants have the ideal condition (e.g. temperature around 25°C), the arms do not curl or droop. When it is too cold, one arm would curl.
To evaluate and compare the two modalities, I conducted a digital diary study of 14 days and semi-structured interview with 8 participants, tasked with taking care of the potted plants with the IoT system, with 7 days for each modality.
Filling out daily questionnaire about their interaction and feelings towards plants and monitoring device
Taking photos of their setup
Completing creative tasks, where they sketched their perspective towards the plants and the monitoring device
Thematic analysis from digital diary entries, creative tasks, photos, and interview.
Example of visual coding (thematic analysis for visual data)
Technology cannot replace direct engagement with plants, although being informative
Technology can act as mediator, improving human-plant connection and plant awareness
Data literacy is crucial, with numbers on screen easier to interpret compared to movement or shape
Affinity diagram of the results
Onboarding support: Including tutorials and frame of reference to help interpreting the data
Visibility: Live condition of plants should be visible to support human-plant connection
Personalization: Personalizing features, for example inactivity, according to the user's level of comfort
Due to the digital nature of the diary study, alternatives should be considered in case the server(s) used to run the study failed.
Analyzing data from various sources (diary entries, visual data) can be overwhelming, thus a system where researchers can easily refer to the main source of data is needed. In this case, I made a tagging sticky note system in Miro.
Tagging system for sticky notes